Contact Center

Driving Excellence Using Call Center Agent Performance Scorecard

Rimlee Patgiri
July 21, 2023
 mins read

Last modified on

July 21, 2023

Call centers agents often hold a pivotal role in ensuring the success of an organization. From resolving customer complaints to building and maintaining customer relationships, call center agents must be well-equipped with skills and expertise. 

However, many factors come into play to ensure an efficient and streamlined agent performance framework

Some of the crucial factors for an organization to keep their agents performing include:

  • Clear Goals and Expectations
  • Comprehensive Training
  • Regular Feedback and Coaching
  • Open Communication Channels
  • Accessible Resources and Tools

A contact center agent scorecard ensures that these needs are met. It is a medium to consolidate invaluable resources for better call center performance. 

Let’s understand what a contact center agent scorecard is and how it can help achieve the desired success that every organization strives for.

What is a Call Center Agent Performance Scorecard?

A Call Center Agent Performance Scorecard is a tool used to measure and evaluate the performance of call center agents. It provides a comprehensive overview of various metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs) crucial for assessing the effectiveness and efficiency of individual agents.

The scorecard typically includes a combination of quantitative and qualitative metrics, allowing supervisors and managers to gauge an agent's performance objectively.

Why Use Call Center Agent Scorecards?

Benefits of using Call Center Agent Scorecards
Benefits of using Call Center Agent Scorecards

Contact center agent scorecards are used for a variety of purposes in order to maximize the efficiency and effectiveness of contact center operations. 

Here are some key reasons for using contact center agent scorecards:

1. Performance Evaluation

Scorecards provide a systematic and objective way to evaluate agent performance based on predefined metrics and KPIs. 

This enables supervisors and managers to assess individual agent performance accurately and helps identify areas for improvement. They can also make informed decisions regarding promotions, bonuses, or other performance-related matters.

2. Quality Assurance

Scorecards play a crucial role in quality assurance programs. They help monitor and measure the quality of interactions between call center agents and customers, ensuring compliance with established standards, scripts, and customer service protocols. 

By tracking metrics like call quality, adherence to policies, and customer satisfaction, scorecards assist in maintaining and improving service quality levels.

3. Training and Development

Scorecards provide valuable insights into agent strengths and weaknesses, which can guide training and development initiatives. By identifying areas where agents may require additional support or coaching, supervisors can tailor training programs to address specific needs and improve overall agent performance.

4. Performance Management

Scorecards serve as a basis for performance management discussions and goal setting. Agents can receive regular feedback and set performance targets based on the metrics captured in the scorecard. This facilitates a continuous improvement mindset and motivates agents to strive for excellence.

5. Customer Experience Improvement

Scorecards enable contact centers to focus on enhancing the client experience. By tracking client satisfaction metrics and other indicators of customer perception, scorecards help identify trends and areas where improvements can be made. 

This allows contact centers to address customer pain points, refine processes, and deliver a superior customer experience.

6. Operational Efficiency

A call center scorecard contributes to operational effectiveness by highlighting inefficiencies or bottlenecks in the performance of agents. By identifying metrics such as average handling time or call resolution time, scorecards assist in streamlining processes, reducing call durations, and optimizing resource allocation.

7. Data-Driven Decision Making

Call center scorecards provide a wealth of data that can be analyzed to make data-driven decisions. By examining trends and patterns in agent performance, supervisors and managers can identify underlying issues, implement targeted interventions, and make informed decisions to drive contact center performance.

See Convin in action for FREE!
Results first, payment later.
15-Day Free Trial | No Credit Card required
Sign Up for Free
Say goodbye to unpredictable conversions
Download your copy

How To Build An Effective Call Center Agent Performance Scorecard?

How to build an effective call center agent performance scorecard
How to build an effective call center agent performance scorecard

Building an effective call center agent performance scorecard involves several key steps.

Here's a guide to help you create a scorecard that accurately reflects agent performance and supports your organizational objectives:

Step #1. Define Clear Performance Metrics and Goals

Identify the specific metrics and goals that are relevant to your call center's objectives. These metrics can include quantitative measures such as average handling time, first call resolution rate, and client satisfaction scores. And qualitative measures such as adherence to scripts and compliance with company policies. 

Ensure that the metrics align with your organization's priorities and customer service standards.

Step #2. Establish Objective Scoring Criteria and Weighting

Develop clear and objective criteria for evaluating each performance metric. Determine the importance or weight assigned to each metric based on its significance to overall performance. 

For example, if customer satisfaction is a top priority, it may carry a higher weight in the scoring system. Ensure that the scoring criteria are consistent and transparent, allowing for fair and unbiased evaluations.

Step #3. Align Scorecard with Organizational Objectives

Ensure that the scorecard aligns with your organization's broader goals and objectives. The metrics and goals on the scorecard should directly contribute to achieving the desired outcomes. Consider the specific targets you want agents to meet and how their performance can impact overall business success.

Step #4. Implement Consistent Evaluation Processes and Feedback Mechanisms

Establish a consistent process for evaluating agent performance using the scorecard. Define who will evaluate the agents, how frequently evaluations will occur, and how the scores will be calculated. 

Provide evaluators with clear guidelines and training to ensure assessment consistency and fairness. Additionally, establish feedback mechanisms to provide constructive feedback based on their call center agent scorecard, supporting their growth and development. 

Step #5. Continuously Review, Update, and Communicate Scorecard

Regularly review and update the call center agent scorecard to ensure its relevance and effectiveness. As your call center evolves and customer expectations change, you may need to revise the metrics and goals to align with new objectives. 

Communicate the scorecard to agents, supervisors, and other stakeholders to ensure everyone understands how performance will be measured and what is expected.

Build Your Call Center Agent Scorecard

Top 5 Call Center Agent Performance Metrics And Benchmarks

Call center agent performance metrics
Call center agent performance metrics

Now, one important question that needs to be addressed is, “How do you evaluate call center agent performance?”

The top 5 call center agent metrics commonly used to assess agents’ effectiveness and customer satisfaction are:

1. Average Handling Time (AHT)

AHT measures the average duration of each customer interaction, including talk time and any related after-call work. 

A lower AHT generally indicates the efficient and effective performance of the agents, showing agents can promptly resolve customer inquiries or issues.

AHT benchmark: 6 minutes. 

2. First Call Resolution (FCR)

FCR measures the percentage of customer interactions resolved on the first call without further follow-up or escalation. 

A higher FCR indicates agents' ability to address customer needs effectively and resolve issues in a single interaction, which leads to improved client satisfaction and reduced call volume.

FCR benchmark: 70%. 

3. Net Promoter Score (NPS)

NPS measures customers' likelihood to recommend a company or its products/services to others. It is typically measured through post-interaction surveys or follow-up communications. 

NPS provides insights into the overall customer loyalty and satisfaction level, helping identify areas for improvement in the performance of agents and client experience.

NPS benchmark: +50.

4. Customer Satisfaction (CSAT)

CSAT measures customers' satisfaction with a specific interaction or overall experience with the call center. It is often collected through post-call surveys or other feedback mechanisms. 

Monitoring CSAT helps identify areas where agents can enhance service delivery and improve customer satisfaction.

CSAT benchmark: 75% to 84%.

5. Average Speed of Answer (ASA)

ASA measures the average time it takes for a call to be answered by an agent. This metric reflects the efficiency of call center operations and staffing levels.

A low ASA indicates minimal wait times for customers, leading to improved customer experience and reduced abandonment rates.

ASA benchmark: 70-30 (70% of calls answered in 30 seconds.)

Tips to Improve Call Center Quality Using Agent Performance Scorecards

How to Improve Call Center Quality Using Agent Performance Scorecards
How to Improve Call Center Quality Using Agent Performance Scorecards

Improving call center quality using agent performance scorecards requires a strategic approach and consistent effort. Here are some tips to help you maximize the effectiveness of your scorecards:

1. Define Clear Performance Metrics

Clearly define the performance metrics and goals that align with your call center's objectives. Ensure the metrics are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) to provide agents with clear expectations.

2. Regularly Monitor Agent Performance

Monitor the performance of agents using the scorecards
Monitor the performance of agents using the scorecards

Continuously monitor the performance of agents using the scorecards to track progress and identify areas for improvement. Regular monitoring enables you to address performance issues promptly and make data-driven decisions.

3. Provide Timely and Actionable Feedback

Offer timely feedback based on the scorecard evaluations. Provide specific examples and actionable suggestions for improvement. Regular feedback helps agents understand their strengths and weaknesses, fostering growth and development.

4. Offer Targeted Training and Coaching

Agent performance dashboard
Targeted Training and Coaching Dashboard

Utilize the scorecards' insights to identify individual agents' training and coaching needs. Develop targeted training programs to address specific areas of improvement and equip agents with the skills and knowledge they need to excel.

5. Recognize and Reward High Performance

Acknowledge and reward agents who consistently perform well based on the scorecard metrics. Recognition and rewards can motivate agents to maintain their performance levels and serve as examples for others to follow.

6. Foster a Culture of Continuous Improvement

Encourage agents to participate in the improvement process actively. Create opportunities for agents to share their ideas and suggestions for enhancing call center quality assurance. Foster a culture of continuous improvement where everyone is committed to delivering exceptional customer experiences.

7. Align Scorecard Metrics with Customer Satisfaction

Ensure that the metrics on the call center agent scorecards directly relate to customer satisfaction. Focus on metrics that significantly impact the overall customer experience, such as first call resolution and client satisfaction scores. Aligning the scorecard with customer satisfaction helps drive improvements that directly benefit customers.

8. Leverage Technology for Scorecard Automation

Utilize technology to automate the scoring and tracking process of the call center agent scorecards. This streamlines the evaluation process, reduces manual effort, and provides real-time data for performance analysis.

Call center quality assurance scorecard template
Free QA scorecard template

Get your QA checklist!

What’s Next With Call Center Agent Performance?

Call center agent scorecards are invaluable tools for optimizing outbound sales operations. They provide objective performance evaluation, ensuring that outbound sales agents meet the desired metrics and goals. 

Scorecards enable organizations to improve sales and support effectiveness, enhance customer interactions, and drive revenue growth. By using scorecards to focus on operational efficiency and identifying areas for improvement, Convin helps call centers achieve maximum performance and success. 

Try call center agent scorecard for your organization today!

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a scorecard for a call center agent?

A scorecard for a call center agent is a performance measurement tool that assesses an agent's performance based on key performance indicators (KPIs). For e.g., call resolution, call quality, customer satisfaction, adherence to scripts, and productivity. 

It provides a quantitative evaluation of an agent's performance, helping to track progress, identify strengths and areas for improvement, and make data-driven decisions to enhance overall performance.

2. What are KPI and which is the most important KPI in a call center?

KPI stands for Key Performance Indicator. It is a measurable value that helps organizations evaluate their success in achieving specific objectives. 

In a call center, various KPIs are used to assess performance. The most important KPI in a call center can vary depending on the specific goals and priorities of the organization. 

However, one commonly important KPI is the Average Handle Time (AHT), which measures the average duration of customer interaction, including talk time, hold time and after-call work. 

3. What Do the Best Call Center Agent Scorecards Have in Common? 

The best call center agent scorecards have the following common features:

  • Clear performance metrics
  • Balanced approach
  • Consistency
  • Real-time feedback
  • Goal-oriented
  • Employee engagement
  • Fairness and objectivity
  • Regular review and calibration
  • Collaboration and transparency
  • Continuous refinement

4. What is the difference between Automated Scoring vs. Manual Call Evaluation?

Automated scoring relies on technology to evaluate calls automatically, while manual call evaluation involves human reviewers listening to recorded calls. Automated scoring is efficient, consistent, and objective, but may lack contextual understanding. 

Manual evaluation provides contextual understanding but is subjective, time-consuming, and prone to biases. Call centers often use a combination of both approaches.

5. What are the common Call Monitoring Form Mistakes

Common call monitoring form mistakes include:

  1. Vague or ambiguous evaluation criteria.
  2. Overly complex or lengthy forms.
  3. Lack of alignment with organizational goals.
  4. Inconsistent scoring across evaluators.
  5. Focusing solely on agent performance, neglecting customer satisfaction.
  6. Neglecting to provide actionable feedback or coaching suggestions.
  7. Failure to adapt forms to evolving business needs and industry trends.
  8. Relying on subjective opinions rather than objective criteria.
  9. Ignoring the importance of non-verbal communication and customer nuances.
  10. Not involving agents in the form development process.

Featured Articles

Contact Center

Mastering Customer Service Satisfaction Survey Analysis

Abhishek Punyani
March 21, 2024
Contact Center

10 First Call Resolution Tips For Every Call Center

Labeeb Ajmal T
May 26, 2023
Contact Center

Voice of Customer (VOC) Guide: Avoiding Common Mistakes

Madhuri Gourav
January 11, 2024

Subscribe to our Newsletter

1000+ sales leaders love how actionable our content is.
Try it out for yourself.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Bhive Workspace No.112,AKR
Techpark, A-Block, 7th Mile
Hosur Road, Krishna Reddy,
Industrial Area,
+91 7011464590, +91 8802881329
2093 Philadelphia Pike #5025
Claymont, Delaware 19703
(+1) 6282095776

Say goodbye to unpredictable conversions

Unlock the solid agent coaching framework for free!

Access the full report now

Please enter the correct email.
Please enter your workplace email.
Invalid Email
Thank you for downloading the report
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.